Our Favorite Books: Staff Picks from Chloe and Mackenzie (Fantasy, Romance & Dark Academia)
Our Favorite Books with a photo of Chloe and Mackenzie and moths
Our Favorite Books: Staff Picks from Chloe & Mackenzie
At our bookstore, recommending books we love is one of the best parts of the job. Readers are always asking for our favorite fantasy, romance, and dark academia books, so we decided to share a list of our personal staff picks. From magical universities and epic fantasy worlds to unforgettable romances and twisty mysteries, these are the books we return to again and again. If you’re looking for your next great read, these staff-favorite books are a great place to start.
Front covers of Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo, Katabasus by R.F. Kuang; The Raven Scholar by Antonia Hodgson; An Academy for Liars by Alexis Henderson; And Now, Back to You by B.K. Borison; In the Veins of the Drowning by Kalie Cassidy; Babel by R.F. Kuang; One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig; The Unmaking of June Farrow by Adrienne Young; The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig; Problematic Summer Romance by Ali Hazelwood; A Deadly Education by Naomi Novak
Mackenzie’s Favorite Books
Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo
If you love dark academia with a supernatural twist, Ninth House is one of the most compelling modern fantasy novels. The story follows Galaxy “Alex” Stern, a troubled young woman unexpectedly offered a place at Yale University—not for academics, but to monitor the secret societies that practice dangerous magic behind closed doors. As Alex investigates occult rituals and mysterious deaths across campus, she begins uncovering secrets the university’s elite would rather keep buried. With a blend of mystery, horror, and magical intrigue, Ninth House explores power, privilege, and the cost of knowledge. Fans of atmospheric fantasy and dark academia novels will find themselves completely immersed in Bardugo’s haunting take on secret societies and forbidden magic.
Katabasis by R. F. Kuang
In Katabasis, acclaimed fantasy author R. F. Kuang crafts a story steeped in mythology, ambition, and the cost of power. The novel follows brilliant but ruthless scholars navigating a world where knowledge and magic are deeply intertwined. As rivalries intensify and dangerous truths begin to surface, the characters are forced to confront what they’re willing to sacrifice for intellectual and personal victory. Like Kuang’s other work, the novel blends sharp commentary on academia, morality, and ambition with immersive worldbuilding and complex characters. Readers who enjoy dark academia fantasy, morally gray protagonists, and intellectually rich storytelling will find Katabasis an unforgettable exploration of obsession, scholarship, and the pursuit of knowledge.
The Raven Scholar by Antonia Hodgson
The Raven Scholar is a richly layered fantasy that combines political intrigue, mystery, and court drama. Set in an empire where scholars wield immense influence, the story follows a brilliant investigator drawn into a web of conspiracies that could destabilize the entire realm. As hidden alliances and betrayals emerge, the protagonist must rely on intellect, cunning, and courage to uncover the truth before it’s too late. Hodgson’s novel stands out for its intricate plotting, memorable characters, and immersive worldbuilding. Readers who enjoy epic fantasy with strong political intrigue and clever mysteries will find The Raven Scholar a gripping and thought-provoking read.
An Academy for Liars by Alexis Henderson
An Academy for Liars is a dark and atmospheric fantasy about ambition, deception, and the secrets hidden within elite institutions. The novel follows a young woman invited to attend a mysterious academy where students are trained in dangerous magical abilities. As she navigates the school’s hidden rules and powerful rivalries, she quickly realizes that knowledge comes with a price—and not everyone survives long enough to graduate. Alexis Henderson creates a haunting setting filled with secrets, power struggles, and unsettling magic. Readers who enjoy dark academia fantasy, morally complex characters, and eerie magical schools will find this novel an unforgettable and chilling story.
And Now, Back to You by B. K. Borison
And Now, Back to You is a heartfelt contemporary romance that blends humor, emotional depth, and the charm of a small-town love story. The novel follows two characters navigating complicated personal lives and unexpected attraction as their paths continue to cross. As they grow closer, both must confront their fears about vulnerability and the risks that come with opening their hearts. B.K. Borison is known for warm, character-driven romances that explore relationships with humor and sincerity, and this story is no exception. Readers who enjoy cozy contemporary romance, lovable characters, and slow-burn love stories will find this book both comforting and deeply satisfying.
In the Veins of the Drowning by Kalie Cassidy
In the Veins of the Drowning is a haunting fantasy that explores grief, survival, and the powerful pull of the sea. The story follows a protagonist struggling to navigate a dangerous world shaped by magic, secrets, and loss. As hidden truths about the past begin to surface, the characters must confront forces far larger than themselves—both magical and emotional. Cassidy’s writing blends lyrical prose with atmospheric storytelling, creating a deeply immersive world filled with mystery and tension. Readers who enjoy dark fantasy with emotional depth, complex relationships, and evocative settings will find this novel both gripping and unforgettable.
Babel by R. F. Kuang
Babel is one of the most celebrated dark academia fantasy novels in recent years. Set in an alternate nineteenth-century Oxford, the story follows Robin Swift, a gifted translator recruited into the prestigious Royal Institute of Translation—known as Babel. There, scholars harness the power of language itself to fuel the British Empire’s dominance. As Robin begins to understand the true cost of this magic, he is forced to choose between loyalty to the institution that gave him everything and the growing resistance against its exploitation. Combining historical fantasy, linguistic magic, and sharp commentary on colonialism, Babel is an intellectually rich and emotionally powerful novel that lingers long after the final page.
One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig
One Dark Window is a gothic fantasy filled with curses, dark magic, and forbidden power. The novel follows Elspeth Spindle, a young woman who shares her mind with a mysterious and dangerous spirit known as the Nightmare. In a kingdom plagued by a magical curse, Elspeth becomes entangled in a rebellion determined to collect powerful enchanted cards that could break the kingdom’s suffering. As alliances shift and secrets unravel, Elspeth must decide whether the magic inside her is a weapon—or a threat to everyone she cares about. With its atmospheric setting and morally complex characters, One Dark Window is perfect for readers who love dark fairy-tale fantasy.
The Unmaking of June Farrow by Adrienne Young
The Unmaking of June Farrow blends magical realism, romance, and mystery in a haunting story about family, fate, and time. June Farrow has spent her life haunted by a mysterious family curse that drives the women in her bloodline to madness. When she discovers a doorway that may hold the answers to her family’s past, June risks everything to step through it. What follows is a sweeping story of love, destiny, and the secrets that shape our lives. Adrienne Young’s lyrical writing and emotionally rich storytelling make this novel a standout for readers who enjoy magical realism and deeply romantic fantasy.
The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig
The Knight and the Moth is a lush, atmospheric fantasy that blends gothic romance, dark magic, and dangerous secrets. The story follows a young woman bound to a sacred order whose life changes when a mysterious knight arrives with questions about the kingdom’s hidden truths. As political tensions rise and ancient magic stirs, the two become entangled in a journey that could reshape the fate of their world. Rachel Gillig’s writing is known for its haunting atmosphere and emotionally rich characters, and this novel delivers both in abundance. Readers who love gothic fantasy, slow-burn romance, and stories filled with curses, prophecy, and forbidden power will find The Knight and the Moth an irresistible read.
Problematic Summer Romance by Ali Hazelwood
Problematic Summer Romance delivers the witty banter and heartfelt emotional arcs Ali Hazelwood fans love. The story follows two characters whose complicated history makes their growing attraction both irresistible and inconvenient. As they spend the summer navigating shared spaces, lingering tension, and unresolved feelings, sparks begin to fly in ways neither expected. Hazelwood’s signature blend of humor, smart dialogue, and emotional vulnerability makes this romance both entertaining and deeply relatable. Readers looking for contemporary romance filled with chemistry, humor, and satisfying character growth will find this a perfect summer read.
A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik
A Deadly Education is a darkly clever fantasy about surviving a magical school where failure often means death. The story follows Galadriel “El” Higgins, a powerful but misunderstood student attending the Scholomance, a dangerous academy where monsters lurk around every corner. Unlike most magical schools, the Scholomance offers no teachers and no easy escape—students must rely on their own abilities to survive until graduation. As El navigates rivalries, alliances, and the expectations placed on her dark powers, she discovers that survival may depend on trusting others after all. Naomi Novik’s imaginative worldbuilding and sharp humor make this one of the most exciting modern fantasy series.
Front covers of Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson; Katabasis by R.F. Kuang; Assassin’s Apprentice by Robin Hobb; Alanna The First Adventure by Tamora Pierce; A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkenss; The Entanglement of Rival Wizards by Sara Raasch; Babel by R.F. Kuang; Deep End by Ali Hazelwood; Broken Bonds by J. Bree; 7th Circle by Tate James; Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston; The Prioriy of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon
Chloe’s Favorite Books
Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson
Tress of the Emerald Sea is a whimsical fantasy adventure inspired by classic fairy tales and epic journeys. The story follows Tress, a quiet young woman whose life changes when her closest friend is taken by a mysterious sorceress. Determined to rescue him, Tress sets out on a dangerous voyage across seas made not of water, but of magical spores capable of explosive and unpredictable reactions. Along the way she encounters pirates, strange creatures, and unexpected allies. Brandon Sanderson’s imaginative storytelling and sense of wonder shine throughout this novel, making it a perfect choice for readers who love adventurous fantasy with heart and humor.
Katabasis by R. F. Kuang
Katabasis explores ambition, knowledge, and the dangerous depths people are willing to descend to in pursuit of power. Drawing inspiration from mythological journeys into the underworld, the novel follows scholars and rivals whose intellectual obsessions lead them into increasingly perilous territory. As academic competition becomes entangled with deeper mysteries about magic, morality, and legacy, the characters must confront the consequences of their choices. Like much of R. F. Kuang’s work, Katabasis blends dark academia themes with sharp exploration of ambition and ethical compromise. Readers who enjoy intellectually driven fantasy and morally complex characters will find this story a fascinating and thought-provoking read.
Assassin's Apprentice by Robin Hobb
Assassin’s Apprentice is the first book in Robin Hobb’s beloved epic fantasy series, The Farseer Trilogy. The story follows Fitz, the illegitimate son of a prince who is raised in the royal court but trained in secret as an assassin loyal to the crown. As Fitz learns the dangerous skills required of him, he becomes entangled in political intrigue, magical forces, and the burdens of loyalty and identity. Hobb’s character-driven storytelling and richly detailed worldbuilding have made this novel a cornerstone of modern epic fantasy. Readers who enjoy immersive fantasy worlds and deeply emotional character journeys will find Assassin’s Apprentice unforgettable.
Alanna: The First Adventure by Tamora Pierce
Alanna: The First Adventure is a classic fantasy novel that follows a determined young girl who disguises herself as a boy in order to train as a knight. Set in the kingdom of Tortall, the story explores Alanna’s journey as she develops her skills, confronts prejudice, and discovers her own magical abilities. Tamora Pierce’s influential fantasy series has inspired generations of readers with its strong heroine, rich worldbuilding, and themes of courage and self-discovery. For many fantasy fans, Alanna’s story is a formative introduction to the genre and remains a beloved classic.
A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness
A Discovery of Witches blends historical mystery, romance, and supernatural intrigue into a sweeping fantasy story. Diana Bishop, a historian and reluctant witch, discovers a long-lost magical manuscript in Oxford’s Bodleian Library. The discovery attracts the attention of supernatural creatures across the world—including Matthew Clairmont, a centuries-old vampire. As Diana and Matthew search for answers, they uncover secrets about magic, history, and forbidden love. Deborah Harkness combines scholarly detail with rich worldbuilding to create a captivating story about knowledge, identity, and the power of connection.
The Entanglement of Rival Wizards by Sara Raasch
The Entanglement of Rival Wizards is a clever fantasy romance that combines magical rivalry, academic competition, and irresistible chemistry. The novel follows two brilliant but stubborn wizards whose professional rivalry forces them into close proximity as they work on competing magical research. As their rivalry intensifies, so does an unexpected attraction that neither of them wants to acknowledge. Sara Raasch balances humor, romance, and imaginative magical concepts to create a story that feels both playful and emotionally engaging. Readers who enjoy enemies-to-lovers romance, magical academia settings, and witty banter will find this novel an entertaining and charming fantasy read.
Babel by R. F. Kuang
Babel is a powerful historical fantasy set in an alternate nineteenth-century Oxford where the study of language fuels magical technology. The story follows Robin Swift, a gifted translator recruited to the prestigious Royal Institute of Translation. As Robin learns to harness the power of language through silver-working magic, he also begins to see how that power supports the expansion of the British Empire. Torn between his loyalty to the institution and his growing awareness of its injustices, Robin must decide where he truly stands. With its combination of dark academia atmosphere, linguistic magic, and historical commentary, Babel has become one of the most talked-about fantasy novels of recent years.
Deep End by Ali Hazelwood
Deep End is a contemporary romance that explores vulnerability, ambition, and the complicated ways people learn to trust one another. The story centers on two characters navigating intense personal and professional pressures while slowly developing a connection neither expected. As their relationship deepens, they must confront their own fears about intimacy, control, and emotional honesty. Ali Hazelwood’s signature style—sharp humor, intelligent characters, and deeply felt emotional arcs—shines throughout this novel. Readers who love character-driven romance with plenty of tension, witty dialogue, and heartfelt growth will find Deep End both entertaining and deeply satisfying.
Broken Bonds by J. Bree
Broken Bonds is the first book in the popular fantasy romance series The Bonds That Tie. The story follows Oleander “Oli” Fallows, a young woman hiding from the powerful men she is magically bound to through a rare supernatural connection known as a bond group. After years on the run, she is forced back into their world and must face the complicated relationships—and dangerous enemies—that come with her unique magic. As tensions rise and secrets unravel, Oli discovers that her bonds may hold far more power than anyone realizes. Combining supernatural action, emotional intensity, and slow-burn romance, Broken Bonds is a standout for readers who enjoy dark paranormal romance and found-family dynamics.
7th Circle by Tate James
7th Circle launches Tate James’s dark and addictive Hades series, blending crime, romance, and morally gray characters. The novel follows Hades, a powerful woman running a criminal empire while navigating a world filled with dangerous alliances and rival organizations. As threats close in from every direction, she must rely on a small circle of trusted allies—each with their own complicated relationship to her—to survive the escalating conflict. The story combines high-stakes action with intense relationships and emotional tension. Readers who enjoy dark romance, powerful female protagonists, and stories set in gritty underground worlds will find 7th Circle a thrilling and addictive read.
Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston
Red, White & Royal Blue is a beloved contemporary romance that combines humor, politics, and heartfelt emotion. The story follows Alex Claremont-Diaz, the charismatic son of the President of the United States, whose long-running rivalry with Prince Henry of Wales becomes a public relations nightmare. When the two are forced to stage a fake friendship for the sake of international diplomacy, their relationship begins to shift in unexpected ways. What starts as rivalry soon turns into a secret romance that could change both of their lives. Casey McQuiston’s novel is celebrated for its witty dialogue, charming characters, and hopeful message about love and identity.
The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon
The Priory of the Orange Tree is a sweeping epic fantasy filled with dragons, political intrigue, and powerful heroines. Set in a richly imagined world divided by competing beliefs about dragons, the novel follows multiple characters whose stories intertwine as an ancient threat begins to rise again. At the center of the narrative is Queen Sabran, whose kingdom depends on her producing an heir to maintain a centuries-old magical protection. Meanwhile, hidden guardians, dragon riders, and scholars across the world struggle to prevent a devastating war. Samantha Shannon’s expansive worldbuilding and complex characters make this novel a modern classic for fans of epic fantasy.
FAQ: Our Favorite Books and Staff Picks
What are bookstore staff picks?
Bookstore staff picks are books that booksellers personally love and frequently recommend to customers. At independent bookstores, staff picks often highlight a wide range of genres—from fantasy and romance to literary fiction and mystery. These recommendations reflect the books that booksellers are most excited to share with readers.
What are some of the best fantasy books recommended by booksellers?
Some of our favorite fantasy staff picks include The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon, Assassin's Apprentice by Robin Hobb, and One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig. These books feature immersive worlds, unforgettable characters, and the kind of storytelling that makes fantasy readers fall in love with the genre.
What are good dark academia books to read?
Dark academia novels combine academic settings with mystery, ambition, and often a touch of magic. Some of our favorite dark academia books include Babel by R. F. Kuang and Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo. Both explore the darker side of knowledge, power, and academic ambition.
What romance books do bookstore owners recommend?
Some of our favorite romance staff picks include Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston, Deep End by Ali Hazelwood, and And Now, Back to You by B. K. Borison. These stories feature unforgettable characters, compelling emotional arcs, and plenty of chemistry.
How do bookstore owners choose their favorite books?
Bookstore owners often choose their favorite books based on the stories they return to again and again or the books they most love recommending to readers. Our staff picks include a mix of epic fantasy, romantic comedies, dark academia, and genre-defying novels that we think every reader should experience at least once.
